Bunions and top reasons to reconsider surgeryBunions and top reasons to reconsider surgery

Many people believe that a bunion is a bump that ‘grows’ on the bone, and that during bunion correction, it can simply be shaved off. Unfortunately, in most cases this is incorrect. Mostly the visible bump occurs because of the metatarsal bone moving towards the centre line of the body, with the big toe moving in the opposite direction, i.e. away from the midline. The visible bump is caused by the partially uncovered joint becoming prominent under the skin. In most cases this cannot simply be shaved off, because doing so would damage the joint, leading to more serious problems.

Bunions are mostly not caused by genetics. Genetics can play a role, however, modern shoes are the primary cause. There is an interesting research study from Japan from the early 1980s — before the introduction of Western shoes in the 1960s — where most of the population wore platform sandals. The incidence of bunions in the population was approximately 3 per cent (the true genetic incidence). After the introduction of Western shoes with high heels and narrow toe boxes, the incidence of bunions increased to over 30 per cent in the same population. (Kato and Watanabe 1981).

Bunions develop when there is a muscle imbalance in the foot. The accompanying picture (Image 01) shows a tug-of-war between two groups of children. Each child represents a separate muscle, and the flag in the middle represents the big toe. Just as the flag moves in the direction of the stronger group of children, the big toe moves towards the stronger or tighter muscles. Long-term use of narrow shoes will lead to stretching and weakening of the muscles on one side of the big toe, so the toe moves.

Most bunions can be managed perfectly well with shoes that are wide enough (Aebischer and Duff 2020). It is important to understand that the front of the foot naturally widens with age, and shoe size should be measured and updated every three years. The two main solutions to a mismatch between the width of the foot and shoes are to either (1) wear wider shoes, or (2) have the shoes stretched in the area of tightness.

Silicone toe spacers and bunion splints to wear in bed at night do not work to change the shape in real-life practical use (Tehraninasr and Forogh 2008). As a serious exercise, I recommend putting on a pair of shoes while wearing a silicone toe spacer. You will see that the tip of the big toe is now pushed into a position of prominence, and the tip of the big toe (or the toenail) can now rub uncomfortably against the far end of the shoe.

If changing shoes is not your choice, then the only other way is to surgically reduce the width of the foot. However, there are some pitfalls to consider (Aebischer and Duff 2020). Cosmesis alone is not a sufficient indication for surgery. Bunion surgery should not be offered to children or teenagers. Surgery should not proceed in smokers, as the complications are higher.

There are more than 130 operations available for bunions, most of which do not work well and are of historical interest only. There is no one-size-fits-all operation for bunions. Each bunion has its own personality, and the correct operation must be chosen. If the wrong operation is chosen, the toe can be worse off than before.

Related: How technology is shaping the future of surgery

In order to offer a complete bunion service, these are the minimum set of surgeries that any bunion surgeon must be able to perform well:

The goal of the operation is to place the 1st metatarsal head directly over the sesamoid bones, and in so doing restore the muscle balance evenly around the toe (please refer to the tug-of-war picture again). This is important to understand. Foot surgeons are “engineers of the foot”, and these goals are mechanical and measurable.

A final technical note is to touch on the recent increase in popularity of the “minimally invasive” surgery. The type of surgery chosen should be viewed as a “tool” used to correct the specific deformity of the patient. Minimal invasive may have a role, however, just like any other operative tool, there are also drawbacks. Some common problems with minimal invasive surgery include significant shortening of the 1st metatarsal (with a painful transfer of force of walking onto the 2nd and 3rd toes, and eventual hammer toes forming as a result), incomplete lateral release of the soft tissues, and unstable osteotomy with loosening of the surgical fixation (something to consider in areas where Vitamin D deficiency and/or osteoporosis is a problem).

It is my observation that people with bunions often have little interest in the status of the muscle balance of the toe, but are rather more interested in lifestyle goals, including (but not limited to):

It is important to realise that the surgeon’s goals are mostly completely different from the patient’s goals when it comes to bunion surgery. Surgeons have control over angles and position, but not direct control over any lifestyle-related goals. There is much room for disappointment in the difference between the two different goals. This is why it is important to seriously consider trying non-operative treatment of bunions first, before considering surgery.

Related: Laser-assisted robotic knee surgery advances orthopaedic treatment

In summary, by going to an expert foot and ankle surgeon, you can be confident that the correct operation is being recommended and will be performed well from a technical standpoint. However, surgery is no magic panacea. Always consider the surgical choices very carefully. The foot is the mechanical shock absorber of the body. Changing the shape of the foot can have unintended mechanical consequences. Surgery for cosmetic reasons alone is not recommended.

References available on request.

Dr. Roger Haene is the Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon at Burjeel Hospital Abu Dhabi. He will be speaking at the Orthopaedics conference in Arab Health 2024.

Back to Clinical